Dualism vs Non Dualism

Dualism vs NonDualism

Indian philosophies and it’s six points of view (darshana) vary slightly in many ways, as this knowledge was collected from different sources at different times and and places and based on different experiences.

Samkhya for example is very much a philosophy of Dualism (Dvaita – on which Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras are based on), based on the belief that there are two separate eternal forces, that where never created but exist, in their pure potentiality eternally. They are both real. These two forces are Purusha, the pure consciousness or soul the cosmos and of every living being  that is unchangeable and does not have creative power – and Prakriti, the ever changing matrix of the cosmos, the core of the cosmos, the cosmos itself, in all it’s shapes and forms, both gross and subtle.

Prakriti consists of three qualities, or Gunas, which are in complete balance and pure potentiality as long as Prakriti and Purusha are separate.

These Gunas are Tamas (Inertia), Rajas (Movement) and Sattva (Illumination).

gunas-illustration

Purusha and Prakriti exist in an everlasting attraction to each other. At some stage, when the attraction becomes too strong, they begin to merge into each other.

When this happens, the perfect balance of the Gunas is disturbed. In an eternal effort to come back into a balance, the Gunas move, increase, decrease and begin the “dance” of evolution and life.  The first evolute is created: Buddhi, or the higher mind. At this stage, the potential state of Prakriti is still in a very subtle form and Buddhi (or Mahat, the cosmic intelligence) becomes a discerning and intelligent force, born out of the imbalances of the gunas and closely connected to Purusha, the soul and pure consciousness. It doesn’t in itself have a consciousness but reflects the pure awareness of our self. Here there is access to all higher knowledge.

The second evolute emerges from Buddhi – Ahamkara, the I-Maker (Ego). Out of the intelligence of the Buddhi emerges another, more concrete and less subtle power of discernment. Ahamkara is able to distinguish Me from You. It compares. It judges.

Growing out of this instinct to compare and distinguish comes the lower mind, or Manas – a much less subtle force that we can sense – as well as the five subtle sense potentials through which Manas is working. These are the potential of hearing, seeing, feeling, tasting and smelling. And on a lower level still, situated in the gross body, are the corresponding sense organs – the eyes, ears, nose, skin, tongue and the organs of action – hands, feet, anus, sexual organs and mouth.

These consist of the gross (material( elements of fire, water, earth, air and space (ether).

So the evolution of any living thing, according to Samkhya, consists of Prakriti in it’s potential state, and her 23 evolutes.

From the dualistic (Dvaita) point of view, Purusha needs Prakriti in order to experience itself and live out any karmic impressions that may have accumulated. But it also has to emancipate itself from it, in order to be free. Maybe this can be compared to a mother guiding us through the experiences and lessons of life but eventually we need to become independant. 

In Yoga, we are trying to free ourselves from this dependency on Prakriti by involution, by reversing the process of evolution, by going backward.

We are trying to access through the gross, physical body and work our way, via the nervous system, to our mind and eventually transcending our Ego mind to enter our Buddhi Nature. From here, we can feel the presence of our true soul, Purusha.

samkhyachart

(Diagram from http://www.santosha.com/)

Vedanta on the other hand, from which the Bhadavad Gita draws in it’s dialogue between Arjuna and Krishna, is mostly (although not completely) based on the metaphysical concept of non duality (Advaita).

Only one pure state of consciousness exists that is the substance of the cosmos, the one supreme reality. This reality is called Brahman.

All living things are created from this one reality and are all connected. 

In their individual state (ie our own individual souls) it is called Atman, although they are absolutely the same (much like the space inside a room and outside a room are the same – the only difference are the walls that make it hard to see out).

Everthing else, including our thoughts, emotions and the perception that we are separated from each other, is referred to as Maya (Illusion). This illusion comes from the distorted perception of our own reality, like a mirror that is warped by our own karmic imprints and caught in the web of cause and effect. Almost like we are in a dream, which we are witnessing but are not waking up from, and as long as we are in it, we believe it to be real.

Advaita Vedanta believes that if we can remove this veil of wrong perception and see clearly, experience, remember our own true divinity, we can experience the true bliss, happiness and unconditional love that is the true nature of Atman. Then we become free from a conditioned existence, where we can only be happy IF.. rather than in a true state of bliss. (Moksha).

Non Dualism also has a concept of evolution, as explained best through the model of Pancha Kosha (the 5 Sheaths or Bodies of Existence):

Here, we also begin with the lowest vibration, the densest of Sheaths that is most accessable to our perception, the Physical body (Anna Maya Kosha) and work our way internally toward our true inner nature.

In both cases, we need to have certain experiences that arise from the seeds of karmic imprints that have been planted at the beginning of time. And in both cases our destiny is to free ourselves from these karmic bondages and either emancipate ourselves or wake up from our cosmic dream.

d9930-210560_orig

Another point of view of indian Philosophy, slightly newer and often described and the 7th Darshana is the Tantric point of view.

In this strongly non dualistic philosophy it is believed that everything IS consciousness.

There is only one reality, which has 2 aspects, like two opposing poles making up one magnetic force – Shiva and Shakti, Consciousness and Nature.

In this model both aspects are part of the same reality, but only Shakti is capable of creation. Everything we experience, every living being, every part of living nature, is an expression of divine consciousness. Therefore there is no need to seperate one from the other or judge good from bad, we just need to experience everything with divine awareness in order to awaken to our own truth.

Much like Samkhya, Tantra (Shaiva Tantra, or Kashmiri Shaivaism) also refers to an evolution of experienced existence but adds more detail by counting 36 instead of 24 evolutes (Tattvas).

tattva10

(Diagram from http://www.bhagavadgitausa.com/)

These are all different descriptions of the same truths, as seen by different eyes.

What all these have in common is that we are all divine beings, pure consciousness and connected to each other because we are all the same source. Our true state of being is bliss, an eternal happiness that does not depend on any outer circumstances, and pure, unconditional love, that connects us to each other and all other beings.

The only thing that stands in the way of us experience this true, blissful state of ourselves, is ignorance and the wrong identification with things that are impermanent and not true reality.

So the solution to the problem, according to Yoga, is to resolve our ignorance.

By removing any obstacles that stand in the way of seeing clearly, we try to make our minds calm and transparent. We try to clean and enhance our energy, we create a healthy body, so that nothing stands in the way of achieving this clear state of mind.

And the most obvious place to begin, is in our physical bodies.

By practicing postures and eating healthy, we try to achieve a state of physical health.

By practicing breath control and relaxation, we calm and strengthen our nervous system and increase the flow of energy. By the practice of concentration and meditation, we clear our mind so that eventually all aspects of ignorance, even of a karmic nature, can dissolve.

About sunshineyogawexford

Yoga classes and workshops in Wexford/Ireland. Ashtanga Yoga, Yin Yoga, Yoga for Kids, Yoga philosophy and Meditation.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s